The Quran (4:48) spells out that shirk is a â€śmajor sin,â€ť stating:Â â€śAnd he who practices shirk has certainly fabricated a tremendous sin.â€ť In one hadith, shirk is worse than murder. While most Muslims cast Christians and Jews as ahl-e-kitab, orÂ â€śpeople of the book,â€ť several elements of Christian practiceâ€”the deification of Christ, with belief in theÂ â€śFather, the Son and the Holy Ghost,â€ťÂ the veneration of saints and the iconography of Mary and Jesusâ€”make Christians a target for extremists like those in the Islamic State as mushrikun.
But for liberal Muslims, like me, whoÂ believe in the Quranic message,Â â€śThere is noÂ compulsion in religion,â€ť shirk is actually the metaphorical sin of worshiping negative vices in this world, like violence and power. To others, from the government of Saudi Arabia to the Islamic State, itâ€™s a lot more explicit: identifying everyone from Muslims in the minority Shia sect and the mystical Sufi tradition as mushrikun.
â€śThen when the sacred months have passed, then kill the mushrikun where you find them.â€ť
The Wahhabi theology that Saudi Arabia exports to the world accuses Muslims of shirk if they are Shiâ€™ites, visit the tombs of saints, celebrate the birthday of the prophet Muhammad or even follow astrology. Even ThinkProgress, a media website affiliated with the Center for American Progress, a Democratic-affiliated think tank that argues the Islamic State isnâ€™t â€śIslamic,â€ť acknowledges that the destruction of tombs by ISIS is a result of Islamic theology that regards tombs as shirk.
The destruction of artifacts in a museum in Mosul, documented in a new ISIS propaganda video released on Thursday, is also religiously motivated by a theology and war strategy of destroying any representations of alleged shirk. In the video, ISIS fighters took sledgehammers to physically behead statues, some dating back to the 7th century BC, much as Muslim invaders in ancient times ransacked Indiaâ€™s Hindu temples.
MilitantÂ Muslims like those in the Islamic State exploit a chapter (9:5) inÂ theÂ Quran, al Taubah, orÂ â€śThe Forgiveness,â€ť which reads, in part: â€śThen when the sacred monthsâ€ťâ€”the 1st, 7th, 11th, and 12th months of the Islamic calendarâ€”â€śhave passed, then kill the mushrikun where you find them, and capture them and besiege them, and lie in wait for them in each and every ambush.â€ť
For most Muslims, while the verse is translated that way, the verse is read in a historical context for a time when the prophet Muhammad was in battle in Mecca with his Quraysh tribe and their allies, challenging their â€śpaganâ€ť traditions with his teachings of monotheism.
Itâ€™s also in this chapter that the Quran invokes Muslims to find â€śhealingâ€ť in their hearts (9:14), or courage, to fight the mushrikun. The Islamic State translated the title of the immolation video of Jordanian Air Force pilot Lt. Muath al-Kasasbeh as â€śHealing the Believers Chests,â€ť labeling the pilot a â€ścrusader detainee.â€ť
This harsh interpretation of shirk and mushrikun means the words of the al Taubah verse find their way into the most ominous of messages by militant groups, surfacing in â€śnight letters,â€ť or warning letters dropped by the Afghan Taliban. One night letter called on Afghans to oppose coalition forces in Afghanistan. It read: â€śKill them wherever you find them. Those who give us information about the coalition forces, God will bless them.â€ť
We had clues about the Islamic Stateâ€™s targeted attacks on Christians in a slick ISIS recruitment video released last fall, â€śThere is No Life Without Jihad,â€ť by al Hayat Media Center, a propaganda wing of ISIS, featuring young men, brandishing machine guns and extolling their vision.
In the recruitment video, a young man,Â identifiedÂ asÂ â€śBrother Abu Muthanna al Yemeniâ€”from Britain,â€ť a â€śMujahid in the Islamic State of Iraq and Sham,â€ťÂ speaksÂ clear English, a scarf tried around his head toÂ make a turban, a black flag planted behind him in a green, leafy clearing. He says (at 2:28 in the video), â€śA lot of people think itâ€™s just to put this flag over their building,â€ť and points with his thumb to the black flag behind him, like a prop.
â€śBy Allah, itâ€™s not that,â€ť he says, waving his hand. â€śItâ€™s about implementing the law of Allah.â€ť
But he goes on to equate shirk with fitna, which meansÂ â€śconflictâ€ť orÂ â€śdiscordâ€ť within the Muslim community, and which Islamic scholars of all persuasions say the Quran forbids.
For many of us,Â fitnaÂ and mushrikun are loaded words in Islam, meant to discredit, silence and even put a target on someoneâ€™s back, including another Muslim.Â I first heard the word fitna when I prayed behind the men at my local mosque in Morgantown, W.V., rather than in a secluded balcony. â€śSister, you are causing fitna!â€ť a man yelled at me.
The Islamic State has used its interpretation of shirk to put a â€śveneer of ideology and pietyâ€ť on the kidnapping of women from another religious group, the Yazidi ethnic minority of Iraq and Syria, says a critique published by the Tony Blair Faith Foundation, a nonprofit group established by the former British prime minister.
In its fourth issue of the Islamic Stateâ€™s magazine, Dabiq, â€śThe Failed Crusade,â€ť published last October, the Islamic State published an article, â€śThe Revival of Slavery Before the Hour,â€ť justifying its enslavement of women from the minority Yazidi ethnicity of Iraq and Syria, saying the Yazidi are â€śmushrikun.â€ť
It argues the Quran commands the enslavement of the Yazidi, as the mushrikun were sold by the Companions,â€ť of the prophet Muhammad in the 7th century. It further cites a hadith telling Muslims to restart slavery as a condition of end times.
The magazine title, Dabiq, itself is a reference to the city of Dabiq that will be captured in the realization of Islamic end times prophecy.
Since the 9/11 attacks, some Muslim organizations and leaders have promoted the idea that Christians, Jews, and Muslims are respected by Muslims as â€śpeople of the Book.â€ťÂ But sadly, translations of the Quran by the government of Saudi Arabia has fed hatred of Jews and Christians. A translation of the first chapter, al Fatiha, â€śThe Opening,â€ť by a moderate translator, Yousuf Ali, reads, â€śShow us the straight way, the way of those on whom Thou hast bestowed Thy Grace, those whose (portion) is not wrath, and who go not astray.â€ť
A translation by theÂ governmentÂ ofÂ Saudi Arabia reads, â€śGuide us on the Straight Way, the Way of those whom You have bestowed Your Grace, not (the way) of those who earned Your Anger (such as the Jews), and not of those who went astray (such as the Christians).â€ť The parenthetical phrases are explicitly added by the government.
What is interesting is that the first fitna in Islamic history is documented as a conflict by Muslims against Muslims. In 657, IslamicÂ historians document theÂ â€śfirst civil war,â€ť at the Battle of Sifin, when a group of Muslims, called the Kharijites, orÂ â€śthose who break away,â€ť started theÂ practice ofÂ takfir, or declaring Muslims apostates.Â Today, ISIS is the most active practitioner of takfirism, which, ironically, is what is causing much of the discord within Islam and the wider world.
Itâ€™s critical for Muslim thought leaders to eliminate this politics of shirk from our communities, making it so that Muslims everywhere can live without judgment of other people for their beliefs and instead in peaceful coexistence. We most certainly have to reject the interpretations of the Quran that are used to sanction violence against mushrikun.