(Prompted by the discussion on this post.)

As a user-moderated question and answer site, the decision of what sorts of questions are and are not allowed is obviously up to the users themselves. However, since most user-moderation tasks require large amounts of karma to exercise, we are currently not at a stage where the users themselves have enough power to prevent abusive or off-topic posts from flooding the board.

As such, it is up to the designated Moderators (Al Ummat, NesreenA, Jenny_ and goldPseudo) to ensure the site remains viable until the userbase can build up enough karma and site experience to manage things in a more democratic fashion. One significant part of our duties is to ensure that posts follow the rules (as laid out in the FAQ).

It has been pointed out the the matter of deciding whether or not a question is "too subjective" is in and of itself subjective; what one Moderator decides is a problem could be seen as perfectly fine by another, and I agree with the concern this raises. Unlike the regular users, Moderators have the ability to unilaterally close and delete any post that they don't like. When the userbase develops to a point where it can handle the user-moderation tasks, this will not be as much a problem and the Moderators would only need to be called in to handle exceptional situations.

But right now, we're all you have.

Above all else, this is a site for the users. So I'm throwing this question out for both the Moderators and the users themselves.

Under what circumstances should the moderators use their powers to close questions?

asked 295215 goldPseudo's gravatar image
edited May 07 '12 at 13:06 Al Ummat ♦ 31877 Al%20Ummat's gravatar image

@caabi we will like to hear what you think cling a question should be handled.

(Apr 27 '12 at 19:16) Al Ummat ♦ Al%20Ummat's gravatar image

Any new users to the site will be confronted by the front page of the site before they read the FAQ -- there is a very good chance they'll not bother to read the FAQ at all -- and they will judge what is or is not acceptable based on the posts they see. As such, it is important for the moderators to make sure that the front page is representative of how a new user is supposed to act.

If a new user sees argumentative posts, they'll instantly assume that argumentative posts are acceptable. If a new user sees "brainteaser" type questions, they'll instantly assume that brainteasers are acceptable. If a new user sees vague and subjective questions with no definite answer, again they'll assume such is acceptable.

If, however, they see any posts that are either closed or downvoted by the community, quickly and decisively, then they're likely to realize that such posts are not welcome here. Or at least know what to expect if they try to post the same.

If we want them to come in posting well-written questions with clear and precise answers, then that is what we should be showing them.

Discussing every decision to close with the other moderators is good in theory, but it relies on all moderators being reachable in a timely fashion; my personal take on this issue is that a moderator needs to be able to make snap decisions to keep the front page clear. In order to build a community of people who understand exactly what sort of question and answer site this is supposed to be, we need to take a hard hand and make sure that any new users that arrive see exactly what they're supposed to see; a Q&A site where "finding answers to existing questions - and getting answers to new questions - can be done without any distractions." (from the FAQ)

Sure, there might some mistakes; snap decisions are never foolproof. But closing questions is not the end of the world, a closed question can easily be reopened by another moderator or by any user with enough karma. And there's nothing stopping the original poster from reformulating the post as a new (and hopefully better) question, or even appealing the decision with a "Why was my question closed?"-type post.

link
answered 295215 goldPseudo's gravatar image

ok, than maybe we can write the conditions in wich the moderator should take / follow when closing a question, what doyou think? I certainly agree about setting the example on the front page, we should do that with islam in our daily lives.

(Apr 25 '12 at 20:34) Al Ummat ♦ Al%20Ummat's gravatar image
1

One reason I decided to post this as a new question instead of keeping it in comments is so that the users who want their say (@confusedsoul I'm looking at you) can post their suggestions as answers and then everyone can vote on whether they're good or bad. Keeps everything nice and democratic.

(Apr 25 '12 at 20:50) goldPseudo ♦ goldPseudo's gravatar image

This is a bias and prejudiced forum, I get that. But to personally feel a certain way to people being inquisitive only benefits you. How do you expect to bring Muslims and nonmuslims to a certain level of understanding and civility if everytime you don't like what is being said it gets closed. Again if it gets personal or worse then yes. It is warranted to rid the responses. However the experience I have on here is when a question is disliked or if a hard and scrutinizing question is asked that is taken personal then it gets cut off. Eventually, the "unbelievers" will be pushed out for this.

(Apr 25 '12 at 21:55) confusedsoul confusedsoul's gravatar image
1

@confusedsoul, as far as i'm concerned, people being inquisitive is great. controversial questions are great. it's debate and argument that is discouraged; this site's software is frankly terrible (by design) for protracted debates and arguments, no matter how valid or insightful they may be. what it excels at is finding clear answers for clear questions.

(Apr 25 '12 at 22:16) goldPseudo ♦ goldPseudo's gravatar image
Your answer
toggle preview

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or __italic__
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

×75

Asked: Apr 25 '12 at 17:32

Seen: 1,512 times

Last updated: May 07 '12 at 13:06


©1998-2013 Islam.com Publications and Research.       All Rights Reserved.