IS THERE ANYONE WHO CAN POSSIBLY ANSWER ME WHO IT WAS THAT DIED ON THE CROSS IF IT WASN'T JESUS?? WHY WOULD GOD NEED TO FOOL THE PEOPLE?? I'VE BEEN CONSIDERING ISLAM FOR QUITE SOMETIME, HOWEVER I AM UNCLEAR ON SOME VERY IMPORTANT ISSUES. HOPE SOMEONE CAN HELP...THANKS

asked 251511 mellowone's gravatar image
edited Apr 30 '12 at 23:52 NesreenA ♦ 199722 NesreenA's gravatar image

12next page »

its never stated who was it that died but the quran just says it was somone of resembelence to jesus the reason is because first, god didnt want the prophet to be tortured second, so he may resurect and defeat the antichrist because God decided at the beggining of time that human beings will never be allowed to return to the earth once they died so if Allah allowed him to return it would be contradictory so he was was brought up to the heavens untill the awaited day of his resurection and at that day the true religion will be clear to the whole world and we will be at peace and everyone will submit to god, it will be a beautiful day :)

link
answered 199722 NesreenA's gravatar image

It’s not just a matter to research. I want to say just one thing is there anyone who don’t believe in miracle and cannot show a single example of them. If you believe in miracle then tell me who is the one that makes the miracles and if don’t believe why can’t anyone make one willingly?

The simple answer of this question we all know that someone created this universe as a Muslim I believe ALLAH created the universe and if someone don’t believe just think we have a theory of big bang but what happened before that and why does it have to be big bang why not something else happen. And the biggest truth is in the nature everything happens in such a way I can see there is someone who is controlling it.

If we can accept all the thing happening by Allah then it is written in Quran isn’t it enough to believe that it is true. We humans have so limited knowledge that we cannot even think outside the world let alone the universe there is no end of knowledge in every area even scientists also believe that. So how can we think of the actions that taken (why, how, possible/impossible). In some cases we just have to believe there is so many terms in science that we just have to consider it will be like this we even don’t know why is it happening. So my fellow Muslim brothers and sisters don’t overthink in the work of ALLAH sometime you cannot just solve it.

There is already so many comments for this is post I don’t think many more reference is necessary, whatever just needed now is to believe cause this is the Islam that we believe in what ALLAH said no matter what it looks like.

Thanks for the question I think if you believe with your heart you will find the answer.

link
answered 4411142 UnknownUser's gravatar image

I heard it as it was jesus twin.. you see. everyone in the world has a twin looking like them and it dont have to be a brother or sister it can be someone else the bible thought it was jesus but it was jesus twin... brother you know islam but bible is telling us a lie thats how i heard it so brother i hope you understand

link
answered 66420 Iman%20Nabil's gravatar image

Im not a christian but im a muslim so jesus is not dead if hes going to save us from Dejjal and im just saying but see if you can sorta see islam and sorta study it but you can pick which religion ok?

(Nov 05 '12 at 23:42) Iman Nabil Iman%20Nabil's gravatar image

•answer content must be at least 10 characters

I go to church every sunday and although Islam does not believe that Jesus died, I believe Jesus died on the Cross and the reason he died was because first of all when Mary had Jesus life was blown into Mary direct from God, Mary did not sin and have sex and when Jesus preached the Gospel to a dying nation they killed him because they did not believe that he was the son of God. Now if God blew life into Mary to have Jesus, was he then not a son of God? This is what you need to ask yourself? Mary did not have sex with Josepeh or anyone to concieve Jesus did she? Jesus was concieved by Immaculate conception so to say that Jesus was not the son of god does not actually make ny sense. When Jesus claimed that he was the son of god he came in the form of a man to preach the gospel and because of the way he was concieved was able to perform miracles. When they killed him he could not come off the cross once he was nailed. It was Jesus who did on the cross, if not Jesus, who died on the Cross? There is no answer to this and iof there is no answer, one needs to think again about following that faith. There is no question in christianity whether he died on the cross or not, it is staight he died on the cross. Why did god let his son die? To forgive us of all our sins. Everybody has a phyisical and spiritual sense right? When they killed Jesus his spirit went into Sheol which is the darkest pit of Hell and fought with Satan a dark force or evil spirit and told Satan to let the captives free whether they were prostitutes, murdereres, thieves and of the like. Satan released them and when Jesus resurrected people were amazed on what he done. On the third day of pentecost the holy spirit was poured out upon the people and in the quran even though it mentions the holy spirit in christinaity you have to have the gift of the holy spirit which allows you to have one of the nine spiritual gifts that states in the bible - i.e Gift of prophesy - Gift of Knowledge - these gifts allow you to see spiritually and in the bible it says that Jospeh had dreams and dreams were shown to Joesph that they will try to Kill Jesus and they fled to a safe country. If you have the gift of the holy spirit you will be shown visions, dreams and be able to prohesy which means you will be able to know what other people are going through just by looking at someone. The holy spirit is mentioned in the quran and the bible, however you need the gift of the holy spirit wich god wants everyone to have, so they are not spiritually blind and although muslims know of the holy spirit they are not able to spiritually see, which is one of the gifts that god wants eveyine to have but in Islam, this notion is not as strong as the Christian faith that's why christians are able to tell you what's going on in your life because they have the gift of the holy spirit. It is a gift from god and the holy spirit was poured onto the nation on the day of Pentecoste. It's sad that people do not acknowledge this and still acknowledge the Jesus did not die on the cross but can't give the name who did died on the cross? Also a lot of muslims have changed to christianity if you watch a Muslim Journey To Hope because they aksed God to show them the right path and although Islam states they are the right path - When muslim who even have Imam's in their family they asked god to show them the right religion and Jesus revelaed himsef spiritually to some of them and a White shining light shone around them, so they changed from Islam to Chirstianity and that is defintiely not Satanic. Satan told god because he was a falln angel that he would throw the spirit of unbelief to those on earth so that people would belief in false prophets and religions so that people would go to hell and those that believed in Jesus and prayed in the name of Jesus would go up. In recognition of this Jesus died at the age of 33 and then Islam came and the prophet mohammed (PBUH) Muslims believe and say that he was a prophet each believe in their own - however when Prohet Mohammed died, he did not resurrect - Jesus is the only prophet that resurrected and because Prophet Mohammed is a prohet that stated that Islam was the last religion he still did not perfor miracles like Jesus - Jesus was resurrected on the third day of reurrection - no other prophet did?

I hope that has answered your questions and feel free to watch A Muslim Journey to Hope If you wish - and for those who wish to believe in Islam or Christianity do as you will because when people did not believe in the gospel of Jesus Christ and his miracles, he left them alone.

God Bless Everyone

link
answered 4411142 UnknownUser's gravatar image
edited Oct 26 '12 at 18:41

Brother Good question but seek the truth truth shall set you free.

suppose if war took place .. there is a king and soldiers so the fight began. all of us know the king will not be in front as the chances are high to be killed in war battle As king got so many responsiblity and the power is so much high. eventhough the soldiers killed still king will get diffrent options to save the entire country women childern old and many.. SO if i ask y cant he go infront and fight with enemies rather sitting behind. Its not fair rught. i hopei am making it sense. SO please try to see Our isa (jesus A.s) as a king and he should be protected some how to save the world in future. and surely the man died on the cross will be rewarded by ALLAH for his matryd. as he done a big job. to save his king.And he beleives one day king will save the world with ALLAH 's Permission.. It is a pure logic for me. only problem is try to think in this way many people dint gave a look like this.. So its as simple as that

ALLAH knows the best

link
answered 4411142 UnknownUser's gravatar image

In deciding which is the best religion to follow, there are no facts to say that Jesus was not crucified on the cross in ISLAM and there idealogy that someone was put there to be made to look like JESUS is just ludicrous. First of all you need to back it up with facts. What was the name of the person who died on the cross if not JESUS? This needs to be known and revealed. Secondly muslims are in denial about the whole concept of christian teachings as I was a muslim myself first of all I never experienced anything of the holy spirit and in fact was not even taught to me. Muslims are in denial about who JESUS CHRIST really was and about the teachings and gifts of the holy spirit although it is mentioned int he Quran Muslims have never experienced the holy spirit unless they have changed from christian to muslim and they were Pentecostal Christians all will be revealed as I write on.

Jesus was put on the cross because he was accused of Blasphemy - What made the Jews want to kill Jesus?

In the bible we see that in the book of John chapter 10: Verse 30-33, it clearly states that "I and the Father are one." 31 The Jews took up stones again to stone Him. 32Jesus answered them, "I showed you many good works from the Father; for which of them are you stoning Me?" 33The Jews answered Him, "For a good work we do not stone You, but for blasphemy; and because You, being a man, make Yourself out to be God," (John 10:30-33)

What was it that Jesus had said or done that caused the Jews to say that He was claiming to be God? Was it "I and the Father are one"? If so, why would that cause the Jews to want to kill Jesus? Perhaps it was something else. Maybe it was something Jesus said elsewhere that made them so angry.

There are only two places in John where the Jews wanted to kill Jesus with stones. Both of these occur after Jesus spoke and made a claim about Himself. The first was in John 8:58-59 and the second was in John 10:30-33. Here is the context of both verses:

John 8:56-59 "Your father Abraham rejoiced to see My day, and he saw it and was glad." 57The Jews therefore said to Him, "You are not yet fifty years old, and have You seen Abraham?" 58Jesus said to them, "Truly, truly, I say to you, before Abraham was born, I am." 59Therefore they picked up stones to throw at Him; but Jesus hid Himself, and went out of the temple." John 10:27-36, "My sheep hear My voice, and I know them, and they follow Me; 28and I give eternal life to them, and they shall never perish; and no one shall snatch them out of My hand. 29"My Father, who has given them to Me, is greater than all; and no one is able to snatch them out of the Father's hand. 30"I and the Father are one." 31 The Jews took up stones again to stone Him. 32Jesus answered them, "I showed you many good works from the Father; for which of them are you stoning Me?" 33The Jews answered Him, "For a good work we do not stone You, but for blasphemy; and because You, being a man, make Yourself out to be God." 34Jesus answered them, "Has it not been written in your Law, 'I said, you are gods'? 35"If he called them gods, to whom the word of God came (and the Scripture cannot be broken), 36 do you say of Him, whom the Father sanctified and sent into the world, 'You are blaspheming,' because I said, 'I am the Son of God'?"

There is absolutely no reference to stones or stoning between John 8:59 and John 10:31. But in those two verses, the Jews responded to Jesus word's by wanting to kill Him. What was it that Jesus said in both cases that brought such a violent reaction? Here they are again...

John 8:58-59, "Jesus said to them, "Truly, truly, I say to you, before Abraham was born, I am." 59Therefore they picked up stones to throw at Him; John 10:30-31, "I and the Father are one." 31The Jews took up stones again to stone Him. The first time the Jews wanted to kill Jesus was when He said, "Before Abraham was, I am." The second time wasn't until John 10:31 when they again wanted to kill Him after Jesus said, "I and the Father are one."

Claiming that he was the son of God and as you may know many people in those days did not believe that he was the son of God. The teaching in the bible first of all reveal that JESUS DID in fact die on the cross and on the third day of resurrection he rose up from the dead. The teachings that they say that he is the trinity comes from the catholic faith and as a Pentecostal Christian I believe that this is not exactly the right teaching. The correct teaching is to follow the Pentecostal faith to stop all confusion throughout the whole world and I recieved a revlation that I needed to tell people about the gospel of JESUS christ - First of all - As everybody knows JESUS was born a miracle baby - God is eternal and can do all things. Jesus was born a miracle as Mary did not have sexual relations with anyone in order to have JESUS. That's the first thing, Secondly Jesus started teaching the gospel at the age of 12 and I believe they crucified him at the age of 33 when they did not believe that he was the son of the eternal one. The son meaning that Mary did not have sexual relations with anyone in order for Jesus to be concieved that's why they say that he is the son of god becuae of the way that he was born however muslims still REJECT this teaching and DO NOT BELIEVE THAT THIS IS TRUE, HOWEVER - How else was JESUS (pbuh) born??? He was not conceieved like you and I? This is one thing muslims failed to recognise and understand according to the christian faith. When they say that he is the son, the father and the holy spirit - the catholics believe that he is the son because of HOW he was born, the father because he was born a miracle through the Eternal father and was then able to perform miracles spiritually. The belief of the holy spirit was again true because when they killed JESUS (pbuh) he died in the manifestation of a man to forgive us for all of our sins died just like you and I physically. However we all know that we have a spirit that also lives within us otherwise we cannot possibly live and our physical bodies WILL eventually die but our spirit will live on as it is eternal SO - when they killed JESUS (pbuh) his spirit went down into the pit of hell and fought with satan for 3 days and opened up all the gates of hell to prostitutes, and all kinds murderers, cheetahs, liars, et.c. and gave them all a second chance - after he was done fighting Satan in hell for three days and released everyone that he willed he rose again on the third day of resurrection and this was the day that the holy spirit was poured out on the day of Pentecost for the truth was then revealed to an otherwise dying nation who did not believe in the Gospel pf Jesus Christ (pbuh) and this is exactly what is going on today. People Don't know what to believe because they say that books have been altered e.tc. far from it the Torah w which was written many, many years ago is 99% correct to the books of the bible that are taught in today's society. It is also true that JESUS did miracles and he DID make the blind see, the Lame walk, the Deaf to hear and he did actually raise people from the dead - again HOW? Because he was from the eternal father who created him again HE Was a miracle baby and because of how he was born he was able to perform miracles just like how God the eternal performs miracles including the birth, the death and the resurrection of JESUS CHRIST - As you know GOD made heaven and earth in seven days - separated darkness from light and son on - JESUS (pbuh) came in the manifestation of a man from the eternal father to preach the gospel to a dying nation who again did not believe? - And it was then up to people to believe or not? Also as a muslim I received revelations which imams in the mosque could not explain and because of this I decided to become a a christian m the revalations were confirmation of the holy spirit and this is the confirmation of the death of JESUS CHRIST (pbuh) even though the muslims believe that the Holy Spirit in Surat Al maidah 5 110 refers to the angel Jibreel (Gabriel) he is the message bearer par excellence from Allah, the lord the glory and grace - he is divine this is what they believe they also believed that it was the holy spirit that strengthend JESUS (pbuh)this is stated in the Quran - AL BAQARAH - 253 however when you ask a muslim if they have received the holy spirit they don't even know what it is let alone experienced it and this is must to recieve the holy spirit if you want to enter into heaven. I then got baptised and asked God to forgive me for any sins that I did whatever they were. It was then that I was baptised and baptism stems from the fact that all things are passed away and all things become new - and that is exactly what happened to JESUS pbuh) - when he went down into the gates of Hell or Sheol as some people may refer it to he gave everybody a second chance and it was for that reason why people get baptised they are a new person and then they will recieve the holy spirit and are able to then start speaking in tongues which is a language that angels understand in heaven. I believe that this has answered your questions as a Muslim some people do not receive revelations as they do not believe that JESUS died on the cross but I will also ask you to kindly watch a programme called a Muslim Journey to Hope on the God channel on TV or you can you tube it - where Muslims like I once was changed into christianity because they asked for revelation of the truth - revelations god showed them. You can also go onto You tube and type in Kingdom Connections by Pastor William Ellis who is my Pastor and get additional details if you are still unsure of anything else. God bless you and I hope you are now at ease.

link
answered 4411142 UnknownUser's gravatar image
edited Aug 04 '12 at 17:54

Allah loved Jesus and he did not let him die on the cross.. so he created another man who looked like Jesus and they killed him instead of the real one... if your question is how can Allah create another Jesus just like that? he created him the same way he created Adam and Eve.. HE JUST SAID BE! and he was

link
answered 43114 MrIslamista's gravatar image

Hello my friend . I've heard this response and ones similar quite often . However no one has been able to show me where the "idea" of another man being put in His (Jesus) place on the cross , originated . Where does this come from ? Because I have not come across this "idea" in any book / books . .

(Aug 23 '12 at 13:25) mellowone mellowone's gravatar image

According to Scholars, Jesus knew he was going to be killed and asked his followers to take his place and sacrifice themselves for his life. A young man volunteered himself, his face was changed by got to look like Jesus and he was actually the one that was killed. Jesus's sole was uplifted by Allah.

link
answered 4411142 UnknownUser's gravatar image

View the short answers of following questions by Famous Scholar Dr. Israr Ahmad. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GKTolvs2ApI&feature=plcp For Complete Video : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GQpYQklIJrI

You can also visit www.tanzeem.org/demand for latest videos being released, also We'd be posting 1 video per day, insha'Allah.

You can ask questions & comment. You would be answered officially by the concerned department.

::: Watch, Understand, Share :::

JazakAllah Khair.

link
answered 4411142 UnknownUser's gravatar image

Brother what happened was, when it was revealed to Jesus that the Jews were planning to kill him, he met with his disciples and told them that the Jews are going to kill him. And he asked them 'who among them will sacrifice himself so that Allah will change his looks to be like his, and if the Jews kill him Allah will give him paradise.' A teenager stood up, and said he will. Jesus said to him 'sit down, not you'. He repeated the offer to them 3 times, and each time, only that teenager was standing up. None of the elders stood up. So Jesus prayed to Allah, and Allah changed the teenager to look like Jesus. Then Jesus moved to another room and stood by the window. It was then that Allah took him up to him while his disciples looked. Then the Jews burst into the room the disciples were sitted and saw Jesus look alike amidst the disciples. So they dragged him and crucified him. After that, the disciples divided into 3 groups. The first group said, since Jesus ascended into heaven, he is a god. The second group said no, he is the son of god. While the last group said no, he is what he said he was, the servant of Allah and his messenger. So the first two groups joined together and fought the last group and killed them, hence they continue preaching there lies.

link
answered 1834 Sani%20Tj's gravatar image
Your answer
toggle preview

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or __italic__
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

×52
×24

Asked: Feb 23 '12 at 23:48

Seen: 9,464 times

Last updated: Nov 08 '12 at 07:51


©1998-2013 Islam.com Publications and Research.       All Rights Reserved.